Review a campaign against its brief

This prompt reviews a campaign draft the way a demanding creative director would before it goes to the client, and it judges the work against the brief rather than against taste. Paste the brief and the work: the copy, plus the pictures or a description of each one. It returns a two-sentence verdict and a pass or fail against every part of the brief. Then it checks the idea, how the words and the picture work together, and every claim that needs evidence. Numbered fixes come last, most important first.